The Rutten Law Firm, APC

The Rutten Law Firm, APC employment law attorneys

Call Today: 818-308-5945

Standing Strong For Employee Rights

Begin A Consultation

$1.5 million sexual harassment verdict against Police Officer

A Vista Superior Court jury awarded $1.5 million to a woman that claimed sexual harassment by an Oceanside police officer. According to Kimberli Hirst's complaint filed in 2010, she alleged that she was subjected to repeated, offensive and unwanted sexual behavior at work for several months, including sexual comments about her body and requests for sexual acts. Hirst worked for the city as a forensic phlebotomist. She alleged that the officer who harassed her did so in locked rooms at the Oceanside Police Department or at the Vista jail.

Notwithstanding the jury's verdict, however, Superior Court Judge Jacqueline M. Stern reviewed Hirst's case against the city of Oceanside and reversed the decision. The judge issued a three-page ruling that the damages awarded were "clearly exorbitant" and not supported by the evidence. The judge believed Hirst's testimony "appeared staged at times and not credible" when she talked about her emotional distress. "For example, Plaintiff cried numerous times during her trial testimony, but admitted that when she eventually discussed the harassment four years ago, she did not cry," Stern said in her ruling. "Moreover, if (the officer's) behavior caused her so much distress, the Court questions why she did not report this conduct to at least her supervisor, with whom she was good friends," the judge said. "Further, belying her emotional distress claim, she continued to take jobs at OPD, even when she had the opportunity to work elsewhere."

The city defendant will be given a new trial.

It is extremely rare for a judge to overrule a jury on factual determinations or witness credibility. It remains to be seen whether the judge's decision will survive on appeal.

Los Angeles Sexual Harassment Lawyers

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For a Response

Do You Have A Question
About Your Case?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

The Rutten Law Firm, APC

The Rutten Law Firm, APC employment law attorneys

Do you need help from an experienced attorney?

Contact us right now to schedule your consultation.

The Rutten Law Firm, APC
4221 Coldwater Canyon Avenue
Studio City, CA 91604

Phone: 818-308-5945
Studio City Office Location

Review Us