The Rutten Law Firm, APCEmployment Law Attorneys
Toll Free 888-708-8623
Los Angeles 310-598-1468
Orange County 714-955-4062
Studio City 818-308-6915
Standing Strong For Employee Rights

Weak Sexual Harassment Claim May Still Support Retaliation Claim

Sexual harassment lawsuits against employers require the employee victim to show that the sexual misconduct was so severe or pervasive that it altered the conditions of employment and thereby created a hostile work environment.  A stray remark here or there is usually not enough to sustain a case. It is not enough that the employee herself be offended by the remarks. Rather, it must also be shown that a "reasonable person" would find the work environment to be "hostile or abusive." 

Even where the sexual harassment claim is not enough to find a hostile work environment, however, it is still unlawful for the employee to be terminated for reporting harassment.

In a recent case decided by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal, Westendorf v. West Coast Contractors (9th Cir. 2013) 712 F.3d 417, the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal of a sexual harassment claim brought under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, but allowed a retaliation claim to proceed.  In that case, Jennifer Westendorf, assistant to a project manager, claimed sexual harassment based on four or five crude and offensive remarks. The Ninth Circuit found that four or five crude remarks over a period of time were not enough to qualify as severe or pervasive.

However, the Ninth Circuit overruled dismissal of a retaliation claim in the same case because it was for a jury to decide whether the employee was terminated for complaining about harassment, which would still be illegal.

As such, the case will proceed to trial to determine whether Ms. Westerfeld was wrongfully terminated for complaining about harassment, even though the harassment itself was not severe or pervasive enough to be actionable.  So, in the end, the employee may still recover her full measure of damages.

Los Angeles Sexual Harassment Attorneys

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Howard Rutten - Founder founder

Howard Rutten has the experience and legal knowledge necessary to help clients achieve the best results.

View Howard’s Profile

Location Information

The Rutten Law Firm, APC - Employment Lawyers
4221 Coldwater Canyon Avenue
Studio City, CA 91604
Toll Free: 888-708-8623
Phone: 818-308-6915
Phone: 310-598-1468
Phone: 714-955-4062
Map & Driving Directions
E-Mail This Page
Print This Content

  • founder founder